Chronic cannabis abuse raises nerve growth factor serum concentrations in drug-naive schizophrenic patients
Maria C. Jockers-Schertibi, Uta Matthies. Heidi Danker-Hopfe, Undine E. Lang Richard
Ivlahlberg and Rainer heliweg Department of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy, Char ftc-University Medicine Berlin Campus Benjamin F,thjkiin. Berth,. German
Long-term cannabis abuse may increase the risk of schizophrenia. Nerve growth factor (NGF) is a pleiotropic neurotrophic protein that is implicated in development, protection and regeneration of NFG sensitive neurones. We tested the hypothesis that damage to neuronal cells in schizophrenia is precipitated by the consumption of cannabis and other neurotoxic substances, resulting in raised NGF serum concentrations and a younger age for disease onset.
The NGF serum levels of 109 consecutive drug-naive schizophrenic patients were measured and compared with those of healthy controls. The results were correlated with the long-term intake of cannabis and other illegal drugs. Mean (± SD) NGF serum levels of 61 control persons (33.1 ± 31.0 pg and 76 schizophrenics who did not consume illegal drugs (26.3 ± 19.5 pg/mi) did not differ significantly, Schizophrenic patients with regular cannabis intake (> 0.5 g on average per day for at least 2 years) had significantly raised NGF serum levels of 412.9 ± 288.4 pg/mI Cu 21) compared to controls and schizophrenic patients not consuming cannabis (p c 0001). In schizophrenic patients who abused not only cannabis, but also additional substances, NGF concentrations were as high as 2336.2 ± 1711.4 pg C = 12).
On average, heavy cannabis consumers suffered their first episode of schizophrenia 3.5 years (n = 21) earlier than schizophrenic patients who abstained from cannabis. These results indicate that cannabis is a possible risk factor for the development of schizophrenia. This might be reflected in the raised NGF-serum concentrations when both schizophrenia and long-term cannabis abuse prevail.
Discussion
These results demonstrate that serum NOF concentrations in untreated schizophrenic patients differed greatly depending on their long-term intake of drugs of abuse. Whereas he drug-naive schizophrenic patients who had not consumed illegal substances n the past showed no significant difference in senim NGF concentrations, those abusing cannabis for longer than 2 years showed significantly elevated N compared to healthy controls. This has been shown unequivocally not only by a descriptional data analysis, but also by a confirmatory study design (Table 2). Schizophrenic patients with long-term abuse of multiple substances showed an even greater increase in their serum NGF concentrations up to 90-fold above non-abusing schizophrenic patients (Fig. I).
NGF-plasma levels in 26 male schizophrenic patients who had been kept free of neuroleptics for 14 days were reported to be significantly lower than those observed in controls (Bersani er a!., 1999 By contrast, in our much larger sample of patients, we found no significant differences with respect to senim NGF concentrations between schizophrenic patients and controls. However, our patients were completely drug-naive whereas the patients of the formerly cited study previously had been treated with antipsvchotics for various time spans. It is known that haloperidol can remain in the cerebral tissue for as long as year after application (Konihuber et at, 1999) thereby possibly modulating and influencing NGF values by its antidopaminergic properties. For this reason, a drug-free period of l days might be too short to rule out the pharmacologica effects of footer antipsychotic medication on the NOF concentration. Haloperidol reduces the basal tTGF plasma levels in eight formerly neuroleptic’ free schizophrenic patients (ALoe et at. 1997).
One explanation could he co-secretion of ‘1GF with prolactin. with both being control by activation of the dopamine D: receptor subtype Missale er a!.. L 996) that, in turn, can be blocked by the antidopamine drug haloperidol. Moreover brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF). another NGF-related neurotrophin. was 1-cc shown to be decreased in he serum of chronic schizophrenic patients who were already treated with neuroleptics Tovooka ci at. 2002). However. we demonstrated highly signficant elevations of the NOF serum levels in schizophrenic patients who had consumed significant amounts of cannabis in the past i more than 0.5 per day over at least 2 years). There’s strong circumstantial evidence for neuronal damage by toxic drugs, but only a few ( neurochenhical) studies to support this. Schizophrenia. a disease of alleged neurodevelopmental origin. o begins in M. C. JOCKERS-SCHERCJBL ETAL.: SCHIZOPHRENIA! CANNABIS AND NERVE GROWTH FACTOR 443 1 I
adolescence at age 6—24 years and is thought to coincide with increased vulnerability to cannabinoids. sometimes avert triggered by them (Andreasson era!.. 1987: Linszen eta!.. 994). In analogy to the situation in neurodegenerative disease (for reviews, see Heliweg et a!, 1998; Siegel and Chauhan, 2000). the high levels of NOF observed in our study might reflect the assumed adverse effects induced by cannabis consumption in schizophrenia development.
At present, the causes and mechanisms of the observed rise in NGF serum concentrations in schizophrenia following long-term cannabis abuse remain speculative. Similarly, from the present data, it is not possible to establish whether the rise in NGE levels is due to disease development (enhanced by cannabis) as a stale marker or whether NOF was even already high before disease onset. Theoretically, patients at risk for an unfavourable outcome of schizophrenia due to repeated cannabis consumption could be assumed to be a different patient population altogether and show premorbid rises in NOF concentrations as a risk-trait variable. 1 a small sample (n = I of subjects without schizophrenia, but regular cannabis consumption of at least 0.5 g per day for longer than 2 years. we found no such elevation of NOF measurements in the serum.
The same was true when serum NGF concentrations were measured in otherwise healthy controls acutely intoxicated with cannabis ( 5; Anders and He unpublished data), These findings indicate that the rise in NOF concentrations is not an effect of chronic cannabis consumption per Se but rather reflects the combined damaging effects of cerebral vulnerability in schizophrenia and the chronic toxicity of long-term cannabis abuse. The earlier onset of schizophrenia in the cannabis consuming patients (Table I) further substantiates this hypothesis.
Greatly raised NGF serum concentrations have been demon strated hi chronic diseases such as alcohol dependence (Aloe a at.. 1996) or Behcet’s disease (lockers-Scherlibi C a 1996). They are not specific for a certain diagnosis. but rather are a marker for chronicity of disease, and possibly for poor prognosis as seen in Behcet’s disease.
Our finding of even greater serum NOF concen [ in schizophrenic patients with a long-terni consumption of additional substances with neurotoxic effects is consistent with the hypothesis of an NOF correlation with the cumulative dose and toxicity of drugs. The rise was up to 90-fold of the mean NGF serum concentrations of schizophrenic patients without drug consumption, which corresponds to the highest endogenous TGF concentrations reported for man to date. Accordingly, cumulative doses of ecstasy have been demonstrated to be neurotoxic and exert delayed and/or chronic cerebral alterations (Ricaurte and \lcCann. 992). showing altered glucose metabolism in Positron emission tomography studies in the hippocampus and amygdala of seven chronic ecstasy users (Obrocki er a,. 1999). Previous magnetic resonance imaging studies with chronic drug abusers of various drugs including cocaine, amphetamines and psvchedelics. also showed minor structural brain changes (Aasley et at.. 1993). However, the investigators did note that the study probands had also been consuming alcohol, Therefore, the structural central nervous system changes did not clearly reflect those effects exclusively attributable to illegal drugs, but possibly also those due at least in part to alcohol. To avoid such confounding factors in our study, we excluded those patients who consumed alcohol on a re basis, This explains the lack of a control group with polysubstance abuse but no schizophrenia because we were unable to find probands that were otherwise reasonably healthy and consumed no alcohol. Certainly, this remains a field for future resarch.
The origin of the NOF measured in serum is speculative: On the one hand, serum NGF could well stem from a central source and reflect the central neurotrophin state, especially in pathological conditions such as preclinical Alzheimer’s disease (Schaub er a!.. 2002). On the other hand, it could reflect a peripheral immunological reaction in terms of a cytokine released from peripheral immune cells (for reviews, see Levi-Montalcini el c 1996; Hel er a.. 1998). Schizophrenia has been connected to autoimmune disease (Ganguli er aI.. 1994; Jones and Cannon. 1998) and to inflammatory disease (Lin eLa!.. 199B). both possibly resulting in central or peripheral immune responses.
An argument could be made about the principal evidence for a role of the neurotrophins NOF or BDNF in conjunction with schizophrenia. In the meantime, there are a number of experiments indicating a connection between BDNF and schizophrenia (Toyooka et at 2002) and some indicating NOF as not only having a role as a peripheral cytokine. but also as a factor relevant to schizophrenia (for a review, see Aloe et ci., 2000).
In summary, we suggest that the raised NOF serum concentrations found in schizophrenics with long-term cannabis abuse, and more so in schizophrenics with long-term abuse of additional drugs, reflect the amount of cerebra! damage by the combined effects of a primary cerebral vulnerability resulting from schizophrenia and the supposed additional drug-neurotoxicity. Apart from the biochemical evidence of an additive effect of schizophrenia and cannabis consumption on NGF serum concen ations in our confirmatory study design, we also demonstrated an earlier ons of disease in schizophrenic patients consuming cannabis chronically, thereby underlining a precipitating effect of the drug on disease onset. Those two findings am suggestive of a correlation but further studies are required to confirm this hypo thesis. Thus, cannabis use may be a risk factor in schizophrenia development, but a predisposition to schizophrenia and cannabis use combined (but neither one independently) appears to be linked to increased NOR production.
Acknowledgement
We would like to thank Dr Hans Scherubl manuscript and giving valuable advice.
Source:
Journal of Psychopharmacology 17(4) (2 439—445
V2003 British Aisociatlon For Psychopharmacology (ISSN Oz I
SAGE PublicaUons. London. Thousand Oaks. CA and Naw Delhi
0269—08111200312117:4: 439—445; O38O3